Hello Gorgeous! Beauty + Life

Hello Gorgeous! Beauty + Life

Eyeshadow Sticks That Actually Deliver (Without the Hype Tax). Part II of II

Here are the eyeshadow sticks that actually deserve your money

Rachel Weingarten's avatar
Rachel Weingarten
Sep 10, 2025
∙ Paid

Hello, Gorgeous!

Yesterday I spilled the tea about Boomstick's $7 million marketing budget. Realistically every makeup company out there spends a small fortune on advertising. What I can’t stomach is the constant targeting to then seem like an organic find (DRMTLGY is another brand with a nearly identical marketing playbook).Today I'm giving you what you actually came for, some alternatives that deliver without massive advertising markup.

I've been testing eyeshadow sticks like it's my job (well, I guess it kind of is), and I found some fun options that work as well as or better than Boomstick. Some cost less than your morning latte, some are definite splurges.

Here's what I focused on: ease of application, minimum settling into fine lines, decent staying power, and formulas that work on skin that's been around the block.

Pro tip: Even if you loathe the idea of shadow sticks, they also work really well as a base coat for powder shadow. Apply, wait til it dries, then apply your usual eyesh…

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Rachel Weingarten.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Rachel C. Weingarten · Publisher Privacy
Substack · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture